Beowulf and the Critics (Medieval & Renaissance Texts & Studies, Vol. 248)

Tolkien s famous essay was originally a Gollancz Lecture at the British Academy. Read Beowulf and the Critics (Medieval & Renaissance Texts & Studies, Vol. 248) By J.R.R. Tolkien – kino-fada.fr Tolkien s original essay, Beowulf The Monsters and the Critics, was amazing if only for its impact on the study of Beowulf I m hard pressed to think of any other essay that changed the world of literary studies so completely This essay basically sent scholarship in its current direction, rescuing it from the pitfalls of scholarship Tolkien saw in his contemporaries the tendency to lament the way critics wanted the poem to be something it was not, or to assume that it was what they wanted, Tolkien s original essay, Beowulf The Monsters and the Critics, was amazing if only for its impact on the study of Beowulf I m hard pressed to think of any other essay that changed the world of literary studies so completely This essay basically sent scholarship in its current direction, rescuing it from the pitfalls of scholarship Tolkien saw in his contemporaries the tendency to lament the way critics wanted the poem to be something it was not, or to assume that it was what they wanted, and to dismiss the monsters as tri...This academic work by J.R.R Tolkien, presented in two lecture drafts, is difficult to read I once tried to read it alongside a Beowulf text and never made it through the book This past semester, while working on an academic paper about Beowulf, I gave it another go Tolkien s insight into the text is fascinating, and I thoroughly enjoy his text based analysis which stands in sharp contrast to thespeculative critical analysis of his contemporaries Tolkien desires to, for the most part, This academic work by J.R.R Tolkien, presented in two lecture drafts, is difficult to read I once tried to read it alongside a Beowulf text and never made it through the book ...An annotation of Tolkien s lectures on Beowulf I read a few years ago I jotted down a few passages that pleased me They seemed to shed some light on why it seems to make cinemagraphic sense to have the good powers be Greco Roman and the bad or neutral powers haveof a Germanic Nordic British cast Though that may be changing Hark Of the fair gods of Greece we also hear rumour of wars with giants and great powers not Olympian Yet this distinction is not clearly conceived The god An annotation of Tolkien s lectures on Beowulf I read a few years ago I jotted down a few passages that pleased me They seemed to shed some light on why it seems to make cinemagraphic sense to have the good powers be Greco Roman and the bad or neutral powers haveof a Germanic Nordic British cast Though that may be changing Hark Of the fair gods of Greece we also hear rumour of wars with giants and great powers not Olympian Yet this distinction is not clearly conceived The gods are not i...In Summary Read Beowulf The Critics B and Explanatory Notes A I found the edition I read edited by Michael Drout a little unusual, and it seems as if it sset up for someone who wants to study Tolkien s essay, rather than someone who wants to read it in order to study Beowulf It is split into four main sections Beowulf The Critics A , Beowulf The Critics B , Explanatory Notes A , and Explanatory Notes B Beowulf The Critics A and B are the same essa In Summary Read Beowulf The Critics B and Explanatory Notes A I found the edition I read edited by Michael...This edition is a magnificent work of scholarship on Professor Drout s part his explanatory notes are worth checking even if you catch Professor Tolkien s references, since he provides copious detail and full contexts for the quotations Scholars back then showed commendable nobility, and could write, even some of those Tolkien was refuting only they are on the right side, though it is not the side that wins The winning side is Chaos and Unreason but the gods, who are defeated, think that This edition is a magnificent work of scholarship on Professor Drout s part his explanatory notes are worth checking even if you catch Professor Tolkien s references, since he provides copious detail and full contexts for the quotations Scholars back then showed commendable nobility, and could write, even some of those Tolkien was refuting only they are on the right side, though it is not the side that wins The winning side is Chaos and Unreason but the gods, who are defeated, think that defeat no refutation W.P Ker And Klaeber one of Tolkien s main targets , quoting a review of the published essay by another of Tolkien s targets, R.W Chambers the finest appreciation which has yet been written of our finest Old English poem As for Professor Tolkien s essay, the second draft is well worth reading even if you ve read the final, published version The B draft here presented is greatly inferior to the final version, which shows how hard Tolkien wor...I didn t read this book, but the essay Beowulf The Monsters and the Critics that came published in the Norton Critical edition of Heaney s translation Couldn t find a single printing of this essay but it s so great that I wanted to list it separately As a life long Tolkien fan and re reader of his works, finally reading Beowulf was a revelation It sheds light on so many aspects of Tolkien s world But this essay does the same In it Tolkien describes the pre Christian doom that hangs ove I didn t read this book, but the essay Beowulf The Monsters and the Critics that came published in the Norton Critical edition of Heaney s translation Couldn t find a single printing of this essay but it s so great that I wanted to list it separately As a life long Tolkien fan and re reader of his works, finally reading Beowulf was a revelation It sheds light on so many aspects of Tolkien s world But this essay does the same In it Tolkien describes the pre Christian doom that hangs over Beowulf, as well as the religion and culture that generated it This theme is very strong in Tolkien s own fiction and the despair it produces is perhaps the key quality of those who finally give in to evil Saruman, Denethor, et al.You can also note certain commonalit...Editor Michael Drout observes that this book will appeal both to Tolkien fans and to Anglo Saxonists, and he offers his edition primarily to the readers who identify with both interest groups As a member of that obscure demographic, I must say that Drout s contribution to the fields of Beowulf studies and Tolkein studies is enormous By publishing two annotated versions of Tolkien s text, it is possible to see the development of The Professor s argument and to see the degree to which this semin Editor Michael Drout observes that this book will appeal both to Tolkien fan...Beowulf es un poema pico anglosaj n an nimo, que se considera un cl sico de la literatura medieval Decid leerlo, o mejor dicho, tuve que leerlo porque va a venir en uno de mis ex menes de literatura Y qu bueno que lo hice porque me gust.En lo personal, no disfruto mucho leyendo historias ambientadas en la edad media, son contadas las que me llegan a gustar Anteriormente hab a tenido oportunidad de leer Beowulf, y a pesar de ser algo largo y sus innumerables personajes, es una historia int Beowulf es un poema pico anglosaj n an nimo, que se considera un cl sico de la literatura medieval Decid l...This is the monograph that established Tolkien s reputation as an academic in the field of literature While everyone else was trying and failing to interpret Beowulf as a disguised history of events at the time it was written, Tolkien recognized it for what Beowulf is the first piece of imaginative aka fiction literature written in what was English back then.Good ...This isnt the exact edition we read, but we recently read Beowulf I normally read to the girls while we eat, but this was one I just could not read at the table Pretty gory, pools of blood, guts, veins, it was prett...

• English
• 13 December 2018
J.R.R. Tolkien
• Hardcover
• 461 pages
• 0866982906
• J.R.R. Tolkien
• Beowulf and the Critics (Medieval & Renaissance Texts & Studies, Vol. 248)